best Auto insurance company in New York? (Top 5 Company)
Current Date:July 28, 2021
best Auto insurance company in New York.jpg

best Auto insurance company in New York? (Top 5 Company)

When every year change rates of multiple Auto insurance company? How to find which is the best Auto insurance company in New York?Do you want to know how to select the best auto insurance company from over hundreds of companies in New York? How could be sure that is the exact insurance company for your auto?

Every company has their own insurance policy. In case, which insurance company policy is best for you? Is that high auto insurance rate in New York? You have too many questions like this before buying insurance for your auto. So, keep calm and read us to select right auto insurance company in New York.

How to choose the best auto insurance company in New York?

First of all, collect all the information about the company with takes time and digging. It’s difficult to get the average overview since insurance is so stated specific and personal. So we relied on widely available online information.

Further, we evaluated each company based on their website tools, educational offerings, and customer service satisfaction, ability to customize policies. We evaluated the overall claims process and company reputation by examining the J.D. Power score and Consumer Reports ratings, and analyzed each provider’s financial stability. J.D Power publishes customer satisfaction scores for largest auto insurers each year. A customer experience can help you to choose the best auto insurance company in New York. So, customer satisfaction is important for you to choose an auto insurance company.

Financial rating: To rate available discounts, ease of claims and policy management, payment, and support, contact, and mobile app options, we just used data directly from the websites of the insurers. The insurers also scored points by offering a bigger variety of payment options, customer support options, and discounts.

Finally, a word about the financial rating, this was the starting point for eliminating companies. Financial rating is also important to choose the best auto insurance company. A.M. Best publishes the financial rating of auto insurance companies every year.

Best Auto insurance companies in New York

With term & condition here we mentioned best auto insurance companies in New York. You can select one of the auto insurance company for you.

GEICO auto insurance company

Here is the first auto insurance company in our list GEICO. Who hasn’t heard of GEICO insurance company? It was founded in 1930 to provide insurance for employees of the government. Their lizard-like mascot is one of the most recognizable insurance company spokesmen.

Further, GEICO is the cheapest auto insurance company in New York. Furthermore, you can purchase insurance online or meet with one of their 150 agent face to face. You can also submit a claim or make a payment through their website as well.

The GEICO also offer benefits of having an auto insurance policy. And all of these benefits are going to impact your monthly premiums.

  • Auto Repair Xpress
  • Breakdown coverage
  • Emergency roadside assistance
  • Ridesharing insurance


  • Excellent customer reviews
  • Additional riders


  • Difficult claim process
  • Not the most affordable option

Allstate Insurance Company

Allstate is the second name in our list for the best auto insurance company in New York. If you’re looking for high-quality insurance policies with the opportunity for discounts, Allstate Insurance should be in our short list.

Allstate is the second largest auto insurer in US, and it provides insurance to 15% of New York’s motorists. It also offers over 20 different discounts that you may qualify for as a New York driver.

Allstate Pros:

  • Anti-theft devices and passive restraint.
  • Consumer-friendly website.
  • Local areas have a physical office and local agents and
  • Multiple opportunities for discounts for bundling.

Allstate Cons:

  • It can be expensive if you don’t have bundle policies.

State Farm Auto Insurance

State Farm is the third-largest auto insurance provider in the U.S and it also takes third place in our list. It was founded in 1922. The State Farm Insurance has a history of financial stability and customer service satisfaction. They have servicing about 44 million auto insurance policies.

Besides, the company’s biggest benefits include its mortar stores and agents. State Farm has 18,000 agents that are licensed to sell auto insurance and offers 15 different discounts to New York drivers. They have a strong mobile app. The State Farm also makes it easy and painless to get quotes online, which means you don’t have to head into a local office if you don’t want to.

State Farm Pros:

  • Great mobile app and website
  • Local offices and agents provide in-person help and
  • Plenty of discounts available.

The Hartford Insurance Company

The Hartford is an old company and an old-fashioned insurer. But they still offer some of the best technology in the business. How we forget to mention the Hartford insurance company from our list.

200 years of business history, The Hartford has built an excellent reputation for customer service. The Hartford Company is still receiving high marks of companies from J.D. Power rating. In 2015 auto claims satisfaction study, this company received 4/5 marks in every category. However, they offer an app and the now-standard online account management option.

The Hartford Pros:

  • Top ratings for claims management
  • Great financial strength
  • Guaranteed renewals of your policy as long as you can drive and
  • Several discounts and additional benefits

The Hartford Cons:

  • Some complaints about unexpected rate increases
  • The best benefits go to AARP members.

USAA Insurance Company

When it comes in auto insurance, it’s only available to military members and their families. As a general public, you won’t have the opportunity to buy a policy from USAA Insurance company. At this time USAA received extremely high marks from J.D. Power’s Claims Satisfaction Survey. They got the highest 5/5 customer satisfaction rating, including “A++” financial rating.

Furthermore, USAA customers were extremely satisfied with their final settlement after an accident. Actually, it is one of the most important indicators of a high-quality insurance company.

USAA Pros:

  • Great discounts, including good student discount for young drivers
  • Top ratings, including overall customer satisfaction
  • Superior customer service

USAA Cons:

  • Only available to U.S. military members and their families.

Why New York’s auto insurance rates so high?

Is it really? New York’s auto insurance rates are so high? We have mentioned the reason of auto insurance high rating.

New York City is one of 12 states in the US with a no-fault auto insurance system. This means it’s your insurance that’ll cover any injuries to you or your passengers. Further any damages to your vehicle, regardless of who was at fault in the accident.

You can still sue the other driver if you’re left seriously injured. However, this approach was designed for lower insurance rates. In fact, after studies have shown it’s actually done the opposite. After all the no-fault system leads to insurers paying for more medical bills and they insert that cost into their insurance premiums.

How to Rate Auto insurance Companies?

Before select any auto insurance company in New York, you have to know how it was rated. And it’s our painful duty to say something about the rating of insurance companies. You must know this before an insurer of any New York insurance company. After depending on this thing, the rating has been published by J.D power, A.M Best etc.

  • Available Discounts
  • Overall Pricing Satisfaction
  • Overall Claims Satisfaction
  • Financial Rating
  • Customer Support Ratings
  • Customizability of Policies
  • Ease of Policy Management
  • Ease of Claims Management
  • Payment Options
  • Support and Contact Options
  • Mobile App Options

Actually, this all is important before publishing any company rating. So, is this information help you to know about auto insurance companies rating?

How to find the Best auto insurance company in New York?

If you are in Google search visit the official website of your state insurance department. You can get good ideas from here which insurance companies are smart to avoid.

Check auto insurance company ranking lists.

J.D. Power surveys insurance policyholders nationwide in order to rank auto insurance companies.  They then rank insurance companies on an annual basis in their publication.  Insurance providers are rated in J.D. Power based on claims handling, price, coverage options, and customer satisfaction.

Look at the financial rating of New York Auto Insurance companies.

An insurance company is in a strong financial position is extremely important. Confirm it first. Because the financial ratings can give you extra confidence that your claims will be paid without the scrap. In addition, an insurance company that has its finances in order should have no problem in covering their policyholders and paying for damages. There are two best sources for financial strength ratings are A.M. Best and Standard and Poors. “A++” is the high rating of A.M Best companies and “D” is the low rate. Besides, standard and Poor’s rating system ranges from triple A (AAA) to double C (CC).

In addition, we have mentioned the best Auto insurance company in New York. Now it’s time to select one of these all auto insurance companies.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *